Of Matters Military: We, the Veterans
Major
General Mrinal Suman
We, the ex-servicemen
are a distinct segment of the society and we take pride in the fact that we
belong to the noblest profession in the world – the profession of arms that
ensures security of our country. Some of us prefer to call ourselves veterans
or senior-soldiers or retired-servicemen. However, nomenclature and taxonomy
are irrelevant. What really matters are issues related to our identity, entity
and conduct.
On the eve of the
Republic Day 2012, an interactive session was organised by Headquarters Southern
Command wherein veterans of the three services were invited. It was an
unprecedented initiative to establish rapport with veterans, apprise them of
various developments and obtain their inputs. After a highly informative talk
by the Army Commander, senior staff officers briefed the gathering. Disappointingly,
the interactive session took the shape of a unit Sainik Sammelan. Veterans took it as an opportunity to vent their grievances
about the inadequacies of various welfare schemes, especially ECHS. It was sad
to see that such a distinguished galaxy had nothing to contribute towards the
general betterment of the services. They were concerned only with their own
interests.
For decades, a Command
Headquarters has been inviting all veterans and their wives once a year for
dinner to maintain rapport with them. It is a big affair with the strength of
guests invariably exceeding 2000. A few years ago, an Army Commander directed that
the dinner be replaced by a high-tea in the evening to save veterans the
trouble of driving back late at night. Invitations were sent accordingly. A
total of 20 guests turned up for the party. A senior officer was heard
remarking that veterans come only when pegs and legs (chicken) are offered to
them.
All arms and services
start celebrations of their raising days by paying homage to their martyrs by
laying wreaths at the war memorials. Though invited, only a handful of veterans
attend such solemn ceremonies whereas they are present in hundreds at evening
social functions for drinks and dinner.
Visit any services
welfare housing society and see the infighting, petty bickering and squabbles amongst
the resident officers. All the sheen of their gentlemanly behaviour disappears
the day they hang their uniforms. Some go to the extent of complaining against
each other to municipal and state authorities on trivial matters, much to the
embarrassment of the civic authorities who are reluctant to intervene.
Petty jealousies make
some veterans conduct themselves in an appalling manner. Their behaviour
reveals a psyche of intolerance and unconcern for others. Strangely, many
veterans seem to suffer from the syndrome – ‘I am unhappy because my neighbour
is happy’.
It is shameful to see
some veterans indulging in parochial behaviour by forming religion/region based
groupings. Apparently, the veneer of secular thinking and nationalist outlook that
they displayed in service was only skin deep. Retirement exposes their true
colours as communal and narrow-minded individuals.
Many veterans do not
find it necessary to bother about their appearance. They are quick to point out
that they are no more under the Army Act. At the same time, they do not forget
their rank and are quick to demand courtesies due to an army officer. Shabbily
dressed and unshaven veterans bring a bad name to the services and project a
poor image of the officer cadre amongst the civilian.
Many veterans find it
difficult to forego service privileges. Unabashedly, they hang on to their
helpers (Sahayaks) for years together by pressurising the officers who had
served under them. They brazenly invoke regimental spirit for selfish gains. Such
blatant misuse of soldiers is an obnoxious sight that does immense damage to
the standing of the services.
Even a casual glance at
email exchanges amongst members of various veterans’ associations will show
that the veterans are obsessed with their self-interest issues. It is OROP, ACHS,
canteen facilities and so on. Not a single issue of concern to the health of
the services is ever discussed.
A highly dedicated and
spirited veteran made valiant efforts to create a platform for the veterans to
engage in intelligent and informed debate on matters of concern to the health
of the military. The response was pathetic. Veterans have countless complaints
and suggestions as regards their own welfare but show total apathy towards the
welfare of the services.
Leaving aside a handful
of veterans who take pains to study, raise and debate serious issues, most
believe in boasting of our past escapades and exploits during social
interactions. They are terribly reluctant to put their experiences down in
writing for the benefit of posterity. The common excuse is shortage of time and
inability to get into the ‘correct mood’.
The Way Forward
It is a mystery as to why
retirement negates all the gentlemanly traits imbibed during long military
service, causing a major change in attitude, behaviour and conduct.
Most veterans feel that
having rendered long service they owe nothing more to the armed forces and that
it is now for the armed forces to reciprocate by looking after them. There may be some justification for such an
expectation but it cannot become a one-way traffic.
It should never be
forgotten that veterans are an inalienable part of the history of their
respective arm/service/regiment. They act as conscience-keepers of their units.
Serving troops look up to them for inspiration. Nothing should be done to breach
their faith.
Respect cannot be
demanded. It has to be earned. If veterans want to be treated with due
deference by the society at large, they must behave like gentlemen-officers.
Alternatively, they should live in anonymity without disclosing their military
rank and be treated accordingly.
Public has little
contact with the serving soldiers who are mostly deployed on the borders. They
form their impression and opinion about the services after watching the conduct
of veterans and judging their value-system. In other words, veterans act as
ambassadors of the services. Therefore, their conduct
has to be above board and worthy of military officers.
In the ancient scripture
Sukraniti, the relation of the military to the state has been compared with
that of the mind of the man. And, we the veterans represent the military. As we
never tire ourselves of declaring ‘once a soldier always a soldier’, we cannot
let the services down.*****
SIR u may be right in some of your observations but who cares for suggesstion/ opinions of veterans. The opinions of serving offrs/JCOs/Jawans is not welcome then caring about veterans is just a show biz and that is why the behaviour of veterans have turned that way. the solution lies in the hands of seving sharks.
ReplyDeleteGen Suman,
ReplyDeleteIst of all u must understand that while you retired as a Gen, most of didnt. Secondly while you may have had the luxury of being heard by anyone (anyone at all) no one serving today has any time for the opinions of the retired Generation.
Is there any agency in the Fauj which even lends a ear to a Serving officer? Do you have any idea how many serving officers struggle with the MES, CDA, MoD etc on a daily basis. Is there any serving General willing to hear their problems?
How many ROGs are even handled properly and on time?
Is there any way that even a serving officer can raise any issue to help change the sad state of most affairs?
Does a General have any time for a Lt Col (TS)?
And you expect the poor retired people, who get a rare chance to meet a few Serving officers, to risk being snubbed, ignored or insulted in a party by discussing the future of India's missile systems? or the Siachen issue which even the politicians dont give a rat's ... about.
It is you who needs a reality check. The Services cant be redeemed except in one of the two ways:-
1. We change our Punjabi like mentality where-in Jugaad is the only way to do things. We stop pampering junior civilians, we stop treating our bosses as Gods and treat our subordinates more professionally.
(or)
2. ( God forbid) There is a large scale and protracted war with our (Most favoured nation) neighbour.
What Maj Gen Suman has written is true. We have forgotten what we were trained to be. Gentlemen. Most Veterans do not try to discuss issues that would lead to a better service and Army. Consequent to retirement, they only bother about their emoluments and privileges. They are right to an extent as the MOD does not correct their anomalies that exist probably for veterans to remain unfocused.
ReplyDelete