Why does India breed so many traitors?
Major
General Mrinal Suman
While studying Indian
history in school days, one was repeatedly told that the foreign invaders resorted
to ‘divide and rule’ policy to gain control over India. They were painted as
unscrupulous schemers who exploited the simple, trusting and gullible Indians.
It is only at a much later stage that one realised the hollowness
of the above assertion. The truth is that we are adept at producing hordes of
traitors who revel in India’s ruin. Every victory of the foreign invaders was
facilitated by the local collaborators who betrayed their kings for some devious
reward or to settle personal scores. No fort was ever conquered without the infidelity
of a trusted minister/commander.
Unfortunately, centuries of slavery has taught us nothing. We
carry on spawning throngs of people who can stoop down to any level (even imperil
national security) for their petty gains. Our leaders, media and intellectuals appear
to have a single point agenda: how to generate innovative issues to keep the nation
divided and embroiled in petty bickering and internal dissentions; and thereby
impede progress and bring a bad name to the country. They abhor India’s rise. Let
me elucidate.
First, the leaders: they
are the fountainhead of all fissiparous tendencies. For them, vote bank
politics take precedence over everything else. One does not have to be a
visionary to predict the danger of abetting illegal migration from Bangladesh
for garnering votes. But unscrupulous political leaders carry on unconcerned.
One hangs one’s head in
shame when political leaders extend their support to a delinquent student
leader who seeks destruction of India. Comparing him with martyr Bhagat Singh
is by far the most perfidious act.
Perhaps, India is the
only country that has an ignominious track record of producing Home Ministers
who revelled in shaming the country. One concocted theories of saffron
terrorism to please his party bosses. In so doing, he presented a convenient
propaganda tool to Pakistan. Another Home Minister did the unthinkable. He declared
a terrorist to be innocent in an affidavit to the court. The aim was to ensnare
the opposition
leaders in a false case. Sadly, India’s intelligence gathering apparatus
suffered immense damage in the process.
When
a leader declares ‘it's safer to be a cow than to be a Muslim in India today’,
he puts the whole country to shame. The world media flashes such headlines with
sinister pleasure. India’s image takes a terrible beating. Just to score a
brownie point against the government, he presents a convenient propaganda
handle to the hostile forces. How low can a leader stoop!
Recently,
a renowned advocate and a former law minister told a TV channel that shouting
slogans for the destruction of the country is not debarred in the constitution.
According to him, freedom of expression was of paramount importance. Even demand
for secession (azadi) was justified. As
the interview progressed, one was not only amazed by his perverted reasoning
but also shocked to see the brazenness with which he was arguing. Survival of India
appeared to be of no concern to him. One wondered if one was watching an Indian
or a Pakistani channel.
Secondly, the media
personnel: the less said the better. From their conduct, it appears that many
of them are foreign plants and India means little to them. When a leading media
house invited a vicious and remorseless enemy like General Pervez Musharraf and
groveled before him, it marked the lowest depths of shamelessness to which journalism
could sink. Instead of castigating him for the Kargil war, he was treated as a
peace loving guest.
Both the electronic and
the print media never report ‘positives’ about the country. Ugly India sells (a
la ‘Slumdog Millionaire’); and not progressive India. Remember how a TV
reporter failed to digest the popularity of Modi in the US and tried to incite
the crowd with provocative remarks. But then they get paid to demean India, and
not to extol it.
Immense damage is also
being inflicted on the unity of the country by the media through its Machiavellian
and skewed reporting. Every news item is deliberately reported with a
religious, caste or creed slant – ‘a dalit
girl molested in a Delhi bus’ (as if other women are not molested in Delhi
buses) or ‘church guard killed’
(in reality an argument between two security guards had turned violent) or ‘Muslim driver runs over a boy’ (as
if his being a Muslim is of any relevance). Recently, in a case of cattle
stealing, a leading newspaper could not resist the temptation to add that ‘one
of the five thieves is learnt to have had connections with a cow protection
group in the past’. How cunningly, a simply case of robbery was given a
communal taint.
Petty vandals are given
the coverage befitting a mass leader. It was obnoxious to see two TV channels
airing their interviews with a student leader charged with sedition. The worst
was the indulgent demeanour of the TV anchors; as if a national hero was being
eulogised. The interviews were repeatedly telecast at prime time. Did these
channels think of interviewing war heroes or martyrs’ families? Forget it; that
would have been a pro-India act and that is an act of sacrilege for them.
Thirdly, the self-proclaimed
secular intelligentsia: it has done the maximum damage to India’s prestige and
standing. Some of them appear to be fifth columnists masquerading as progressive
intellectuals. In which country of the world would the intelligentsia write to
the US government not to receive their Prime Minister? Honestly, it is simply
loathsome: duly elected representative of 1.25 billion Indians being subjected
to indignities by a shameless bunch of foreign-educated and foreign-paid anti-national
elements. Unfortunately, their protests get huge publicity abroad, thereby
undermining all efforts to raise India’s standing in the world forum.
It can be said with certainty that
the well-orchestrated campaign of intolerance
was totally malicious in intent. The sole objective was to stall all
progressive reforms by tarnishing the image of the government. How else can
anti-nationalism be defined? As expected, having dented India’s reputation, sold-out media
chose to ignore the true facts as they emerged.
Hundreds of Christians, led by the church leaders, marched in
protest on the roads of Delhi against the alleged vandalism of churches and a
theft in a Christian school. Routine cases of petty crimes were cited to suggest
an anti-minority conspiracy. They ensured extensive coverage of their protests
by the foreign and Indian media, thereby damaging India’s secular image. Foreign
channels are only too eager to shame India. Unwisely, even Obama got carried
away with his uncalled for advice, losing considerable goodwill in India. Reportedly,
he said so on the prodding of an Indian leader.
Soldiers and the national symbols: the national flag, the
national anthem and the national salutations are representative of a country’s national
identity and pride. They symbolise ancient heritage, current challenges and
future aspirations. For soldiers, their sanctity is incontestable.
Thousands of soldiers have sacrificed their lives to plant our tricolour
on the enemy strongholds, thereby earning the ultimate honour of having their
bodies draped in the national flag.
Notes of the national anthem make every soldier get goose
pimples. The response is instantaneous and the effect is electrifying. Even in
their homes, they stand up with their families when the national anthem is
played on TV during Independence/Republic Day ceremonies.
Similarly, national salutations like ‘Hindustan Zindabad’, ‘Jai
Hind’ and ‘Bharat Mata Ki Jai’ make adrenalin surge through their bodies. The
salutations act as a rallying call to inspire the soldiers for the ultimate
sacrifice. All military functions conclude with full-throated renditions of ‘Bharat
Mata Ki Jai’.
Therefore, the current controversy regarding national
salutations is highly painful to the soldiers. They fail to understand as to
how an Indian can have difficulty in hailing the country. How can ‘Bharat Mata
Ki Jai’ be assigned religious overtones.
Finally: History stands
testimony to the fact that a nation infested with the virus of treachery,
deceitfulness and perfidy has always been an easy prey for foreign subjugation.
No one knows this bitter truth better than India. Yet, our leaders, media and
intelligentsia keep discrediting and harming the country through their
seditious utterances and activities. Under the garb of freedom of speech, they
support those felonious speakers who vow not to rest till India is destroyed.
When Paris was hit by
the terrorist attacks, the whole country gave a unified response. Compare it
with our Batla House encounter against Indian Mujahdeen where two terrorists
were killed and two arrested. A brave police officer lost his life. Yet, many seditious
elements had the impudence to term the encounter to be ‘fake’.
Therefore, the mystery
remains unsolved. Why does India continue to produce so many Jaichand and Mir
Jafars? Is India a cursed nation or is treachery a part of our DNA? One
wonders.*****
Excellent. You have echoed all my thoughts. I wrote several blogs on each of the points you mentioned. It's a pity India has so many fifth columnists now.
ReplyDeleteSir I salute you.You have rightly pin pointed what was crossing my mind.
ReplyDeleteI am wondering how to change this negative mindset of us Indians.
The marginalization of Indian Armed Forces
ReplyDeleteThe Indian freedom in 1947 was a harbinger for a much bigger change. First time in the history of about a thousand years, India got a real secular ( predominantly hindu) Military establishment. In another first, first time in known history, India became one big country. Big enough to be kicked around easily. May be it was just a coincidence, or a Divine intervention for a grand revolution.
The marginalization of Indian Armed Forces since then can easily be attributed to some big conspiracy. As it was the main state instrument capable to frustrate any anti India evil design of those who could not accept India to be no more their Apple.
Following may be relevant
1. Indian Military Industrial Complex was never allowed to grow. We were only allowed to import weapons and not allowed to export.
2. Indian military requirement was conveniently equated to Pakistan, so that we never prepare to counter bigger threats like China and remain small.
3. What ever meager we had, we were deliberately stretched to the limits in the name of "Aid to Civil Administration"
4. Our Defence budget was kept well below even the minimum of 3% of GDP, especially when our immediate adversaries were spending more than 6% of their GDPs.
5. Understandably, till date we do not have a proper "National Security Policy" document in place.
6. The serving soldiers have been denied their fundamental right to vote since independence by creating bureaucratic hurdles.
7. The defence offset policy, though was passed in 2006, but it has neither been implemented in letter nor in spirit so far.
8. OROP delay shows how strong the anti-national lobbies are.
Cdr Neeraj Singla, 98180 22627
Srvices and officr hood which was epitome of superior ethics ,are compromised lot.
ReplyDeleteThe concept is of DIL MANGE MORE.
You would have watched a priest performin Pooja ,he talks of LABH. Which scripture talks of Profit .
They only talk of KERMA.WE are trained to think of profit from our early stages
Beg your pardon and would like to differ with you on the use of the word "leader" when you actually meant some low life politicians. But I don't blame you - it has been a while since Indians have forgotten "leaders" and commonly mistake politicians to be "leaders". To quote
ReplyDeleteHe who knows not, and knows not he knows not, is a fool, shun him.
He who know not and knows he knows not, is simple teach him.
He who knows and knows not he knows, is asleep, wake him.
He who knows and knows he knows, is the leader, follow him.
Most of the politicians in India aptly fit the first category and most Indians fit the third. Perhaps there lies the answer to your question of why we produce more traitors and trench coats. The nation is asleep and fools are ruling it.
A few viewpoints..There are people who are truly philosophical and who are very closely identifying themselves with concepts of Vasudhaiva kutambakam , believing seriously in the lofty ideals that have deep roots in indian philosophy. They may be concerned genuinely about divisive tendencies cropping up in the country.They may never encourage conversion that christian missions are carrying out, may like to see that everybody feels safe and secure in this country, they dont differentiate people or religion/eventually could even be dreaming of ONE world like Vethadri Mahraishi, Vallalar, even Tagore was a world citizen.There are humanists whose love for humanity knows no bounds, most of them have been born in this soil including Buddha. While I do agree with you that we should align with our outstanding PM in advancing the stature of the country ,(I do my bit always dreaming of strengthening India) I think there should be space for dissent too against divisive tendencies.This is a country of great values.I am all claps , however, for the deep devotion to the motherland that has come out from your writeup .I also believe that one world dream should start with strong feelings for our great nation in the first place before India can show the way to the world ,the methods of peaceful and joyous coexistence.Just read these lines as a fellow citizen's viewpoint written in the spirit of upholding the grand prestinge of our great country
ReplyDeleteYou are living in a fools paradise to expect adrenalin surge from the greetings and national salutations. That sort of euphoria is limited to the Armed Forces. The public will get adrenalin surge from the Bollywood star's gyrations, from Cricket matches (for the matches won) and Political rallies only. They are all brain washed over a period of times to be selfish.
ReplyDeleteI fully agree with these comments. We need to inculcate nationalism into our children at a very young age so that they grow up to become proud citizens of India. "We are proud Indians" should be part of our growing up slogan so that it gets inculcated in our DNA.
ReplyDelete